Last updated: November 2026. Some links on this page are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you buy, at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and does not change our picks.
Mascara is one of the most-used makeup products in the world and also one of the easiest to get wrong. The wrong formula flakes by lunchtime, smudges under your eyes, clumps your lashes together, or leaves them stiff and dry. The right one makes your eyes look more open and awake in about thirty seconds.
The problem is that there is no single best mascara for everyone. The best pick depends on your lashes (short, straight, sparse, or already long), what you want (length, volume, curl, or a natural look), and how your eyes behave (sensitive, watery, or sitting behind contact lenses). This guide gives you our top picks for 2026, explains how to choose, and covers application, removal, and eye safety.
What is the best mascara overall?
Here are the quick picks. Details on each one come further down.
- Best overall: Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions
- Best drugstore for length and lift: Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High
- Best drugstore for volume: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise
- Best budget buy: Essence Lash Princess
- Best tubing mascara: Tarte Tartelette Tubing
- Best waterproof: Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Waterproof
- Best clean-beauty pick: Ilia Limitless Lash
- Best long-wearing: Clinique High Impact High-Fi Full Volume Water-Resistant
- Best for curl and length: Benefit They’re Real!
- Best classic: Lancôme Hypnôse Drama
How did we choose these mascaras?
We want to be upfront about this. We have not personally tested every mascara on this list, and we will not pretend that we did. These picks come from three things: published testing and best-of lists from beauty and shopping publications (for example, Marie Claire’s 2026 tested roundup and Shop TODAY’s editor tests), the features of each formula and brush, and how often a product keeps showing up as a recommendation.
Because formulas, brushes, and prices change, always check the current ingredient list and recent reviews before you buy. If a product description here does not match what you see on the box, trust the box.
How do I choose the right mascara for my lashes?
Start with what you want your lashes to do, then look at the brush and the formula.
1. Decide your goal.
- Length: look for a thin, defined brush that reaches the roots and the tips.
- Volume: look for a larger brush or a thicker formula that builds up with extra coats.
- Curl and lift: look for a curved brush, a formula that holds a curl, and an eyelash curler used before you apply it.
- Natural definition: look for a lighter formula that separates lashes without clumping.
2. Look at the brush.
- Silicone or molded brushes tend to separate lashes and are good for definition and precision. They suit short or fine lashes.
- Bristle brushes tend to hold more product, so they build volume more easily. They can clump if you are heavy-handed.
- Curved brushes help lift. Tiny brushes help reach short corner lashes and the lower lashes.
3. Pick a formula type.
- Regular mascara is the easiest to wear and remove.
- Waterproof or water-resistant mascara holds up to humidity, tears, and swimming but needs an oil-based remover.
- Tubing mascara forms tiny tubes around each lash. It resists smudging and comes off with warm water.
- Washable (flake-free) formulas come off with your cleanser, which can be gentler on lashes.
4. Think about your eyes. If your eyes are sensitive or watery, or you wear contact lenses, choose a fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested formula and avoid anything that flakes easily.
5. Pick a shade. Black gives the most definition. Brown-black or brown looks softer and works well for lighter hair and skin.
What are the best mascaras in 2026?
1. Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions — Best Overall
Marie Claire’s editors named this their best mascara overall in their 2026 tested roundup, and other editor lists have recommended it too. It is known for lengthened, separated lashes without a heavy or stiff feel, and it is a good all-rounder if you want one mascara that looks clean and defined.
- Best for: everyday length and separation
- Keep in mind: it costs more than drugstore options, so check the current price and whether the brand offers refills or deals.

2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High — Best Drugstore Pick for Length and Lift

This is one of the most frequently recommended drugstore mascaras in 2026 best-of lists. The flexible, curved brush is designed to reach every lash from root to tip, and users like the long, lifted look. It is easy to find and sits at a drugstore price.
- Best for: long, lifted lashes without spending much
- Keep in mind: it gives length more than heavy volume, so layer a second coat if you want more drama.
3. L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise — Best Drugstore Pick for Volume
A long-time drugstore favorite for fuller-looking lashes. The soft, dense brush deposits plenty of product, so you can build from a natural look to a fuller one in two or three coats. It is commonly recommended on drugstore best-of lists.
- Best for: full, fluttery volume on a budget
- Keep in mind: build it slowly and comb through while it is wet, so the lashes do not clump.
4. Essence Lash Princess—Best Budget Buy
Shop TODAY included the Lash Princess waterproof version in its editor-tested picks, and the standard formula is a cult budget favorite. It offers a fuller, curled look at a very low price. If you are new to mascara or you replace it often, this is an easy and low-risk choice.
- Best for: the lowest price with a dramatic look
- Keep in mind: the formula can feel heavy, so go lightly and comb through to avoid clumps.

5. Tarte Tartelette Tubing—Best Tubing Mascara
A popular tubing mascara that coats each lash in a flexible tube, which helps it resist smudging and flaking. It comes off with warm water, so you do not need to scrub your eyes. It suits people who struggle with smudges or raccoon eyes by the afternoon.
- Best for: smudge-resistance and easy removal
- Keep in mind: tubing mascara often needs warm water and a little patience to come off, so give it time to soften.
6. Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Waterproof — Best Waterproof Luxury Pick

Marie Claire named this the best waterproof mascara in its 2026 roundup. It is designed for dramatic volume that stays put in heat, humidity, and tears, which makes it useful for weddings, travel, and events.
- Best for: high-volume, long-wearing waterproof wear
- Keep in mind: waterproof formulas need an oil-based remover, so remove it gently instead of rubbing.
7. Ilia Limitless Lash—Best Clean-Beauty Pick
Ilia is a clean-beauty brand, and this mascara regularly appears in 2026 lists for people who want a cleaner ingredient list alongside lengthened, defined lashes. It is a good choice if you care about what is in your makeup.
- Best for: lengthened lashes with a cleaner formula
- Keep in mind: “clean” is a marketing term and not a guarantee that something suits your eyes, so still read the ingredient list.
Check the current price:
8. Clinique High Impact High-Fi Full Volume Water-Resistant—Best Long-Wearing Pick
Shop TODAY’s tester picked this as the best long-lasting formula and scored it highly for formula and volume. The same tester noted that the formula dried faster than the others and caused some flaking, so keep that in mind if you wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes.
- Best for: long wear and bold volume
- Keep in mind: if you notice flaking, apply thinner coats and replace the tube on schedule.
9. Benefit They’re Real!—Best for Curl and Length
A long-time favorite for people who want longer, curled-looking lashes. The brush is designed to grab short lashes and corner lashes, so it can help if your lashes are sparse or straight.
- Best for: curl and length on short, straight lashes
- Keep in mind: the formula is fairly intense, so it can feel heavier on delicate lashes. Use a gentle remover.
10. Lancôme Hypnôse Drama — Best Classic
A popular, widely loved mascara for a bold, dramatic look. It is a good choice if you want a classic, high-volume formula from a department-store brand. Some roundups also recommend Lancôme mascaras for people with sensitive eyes, but check the packaging and ingredient list yourself, because formulas vary.
- Best for: bold, dramatic volume
- Keep in mind: it is a premium-priced product, so compare it with the drugstore picks above before you decide.
Check the current price:
What is the difference between regular, waterproof, and tubing mascara?
Regular mascara is the easiest to apply and remove. It can smudge if your eyes water or the weather is humid, so it suits everyday wear.
Waterproof (or water-resistant) mascara holds up to humidity, sweat and tears. The trade-off is that it is harder to remove and can feel drying on lashes if you pull or rub, so use a gentle oil-based eye makeup remover.
Tubing mascara wraps each lash in a tiny flexible tube. Brands describe it as smudge-proof, and it usually comes off with warm water. It can take a little patience to remove.
Washable or flake-free mascara comes off with your normal cleanser. It is often a good fit if you wear contacts, but it may not last as well in very humid weather.
If you are not sure, start with a regular or washable formula for everyday wear, and keep a waterproof one for events.
How do I apply mascara for the best results?
- Curl first. An eyelash curler before mascara helps your lashes hold a lift. Be gentle and never curl lashes after applying mascara, because that can pull them out.
- Wipe the wand. Remove extra product on the tube’s rim before you apply it, so you do not get clumps.
- Start at the roots. Press the wand to the base of your upper lashes and wiggle it side to side, then sweep upward to the tips.
- Use the tip for corners and lower lashes. Hold the wand vertically to reach small lashes.
- Layer, do not pile. Let the first coat set for a few seconds before adding a second thin coat. Comb through with a clean spoolie while it is still wet if you see clumps.
- Do not pump the wand. Pumping pushes air into the tube, which dries it out faster and does not add more product to the brush. Twist the wand in the tube instead.
If you get mascara on your eyelid, let it dry and then lift it off with a cotton swab, instead of smearing it.
Our guides to the best concealer for dark circles and the best BB cream can help you finish the rest of your eye and face makeup.
How do I remove mascara without hurting my lashes?
Rubbing is the biggest cause of lash damage, so be gentle.
- For regular and washable mascara, a micellar water or gentle cleanser on a cotton pad is usually enough. Hold the pad against your closed eye for ten seconds to dissolve the makeup, and then wipe down gently.
- For waterproof mascara, use an oil-based or bi-phase eye makeup remover. Press, wait and wipe. Do not scrub.
- For tubing mascara, soak your lashes with warm water or a warm, damp cloth, then slide the tubes off with your fingers.
Always remove mascara before bed. Sleeping in it can irritate your eyes and make your lashes brittle.
How often should I replace mascara?
Most brands and eye doctors recommend replacing mascara about every three months. The tube is dark and moist, and every time you use it you introduce bacteria from your eyes and hands. An old tube can irritate your eyes and cause infections.
Replace it sooner if it smells odd, has gone dry or clumpy, or you have had an eye infection or a stye. Do not add water, saliva or any liquid to revive a dry mascara. Never share mascara with anyone. Write the date you opened it on the tube, and you will know when to toss it.
Can mascara cause irritation or eye problems?
Used properly, mascara is safe for most people. Problems usually come from old products, shared products, flaking or leftover makeup.
- Irritation or redness: try a fragrance-free, ophthalmologist-tested formula and check whether the tube is old.
- Flakes in your eyes: switch to a tubing or washable formula, and use thinner coats.
- Allergic reactions: swelling, itching or a rash around the eyes can point to an allergy. Stop using the product.
- Infections: pain, a lump, discharge or ongoing redness need to be checked by a doctor. Throw the mascara away.
This guide is general information and not medical advice. If you have pain, vision changes, swelling or symptoms that do not settle, see an eye doctor.
Which mascara is best for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers?
For sensitive eyes, look for fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested on the label, and keep the ingredient list short. Avoid formulas that flake, because flakes can irritate your eyes, especially under contacts. Tubing and washable mascaras are often a good fit, because they tend to flake less and come off easily.
If you wear contact lenses, put your lenses in before you apply mascara, and remove them before you take off your makeup. Check with your eye doctor if you have ongoing irritation.
What is the best mascara for short lashes?
A brush with a small, precise tip helps you reach short lashes, and a curler before you apply helps them look longer. A formula that focuses on length, such as a thin silicone brush, tends to work better than a very heavy volumizing one.
What is the best drugstore mascara?
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High and L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise are both frequently recommended in 2026 best-of lists. The first leans toward length and lift, and the second toward volume. essence Lash Princess is a strong budget pick.
Is waterproof mascara bad for your lashes?
Not automatically. The issue is usually how it is removed. Rubbing and pulling can break lashes, so use an oil-based remover, press and wait for it to dissolve, and wipe gently.
Should I wear mascara every day?
There is no rule against it, as long as you remove it every night, replace it every few months and stop if your eyes are irritated. Taking a day off now and then is fine.
How can I stop my mascara from smudging?
Prime your lids and let your eye makeup set, choose a tubing or waterproof formula, and avoid heavy eye creams right under your lashes. Oily lids and watery eyes are the most common causes.
What is the bottom line?
The best mascara is the one that fits your lashes, your eyes and your routine. If you want a single pick, Thrive Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions is our top overall choice, based on editor testing. If you are shopping on a budget, Maybelline Sky High and L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise are strong drugstore options, and essence Lash Princess is a great low-cost buy. For smudge-proof wear, try Tarte Tartelette Tubing. For waterproof drama, try YSL Lash Clash Waterproof.
Whichever you choose, apply it gently, remove it fully every night and replace it about every three months. Your eyes and your lashes will thank you.
What do you want your mascara to do: length, volume, curl or all three? Tell us your lash type and we will point you to the best match.